Homeowners insurance has always been an important part of purchasing real estate, but in recent years it has become a much more significant factor in the home buying process. Rising construction costs, inflation, severe weather events, increasing wildfire losses, and changes in the insurance marketplace have caused insurance premiums to increase dramatically throughout California. In some areas, insurance companies have reduced the number of policies they issue or have stopped writing new policies altogether. As a result, obtaining affordable homeowners insurance has become one of the greatest challenges facing California homebuyers.
From a lender’s perspective, adequate property insurance is not optional. Because the home serves as collateral for the mortgage loan, the lender wants to ensure that the property can be repaired or rebuilt if it suffers damage from a covered loss. If a borrower cannot obtain acceptable insurance or the cost of insurance causes the borrower’s debt-to-income ratio to exceed underwriting guidelines, the loan may be denied even if the borrower otherwise qualifies.
Why Lenders Require Homeowners Insurance
A mortgage loan is secured by the real property being financed. If the property is destroyed by fire, vandalism, wind, or another covered event, the lender’s collateral could lose significant value. Homeowners insurance helps protect both the borrower and the lender by providing funds to repair or rebuild the property after a covered loss.
Before funding a loan, the lender typically requires the borrower to obtain a homeowners insurance policy that meets the lender’s minimum requirements. The lender will usually be listed on the policy as the mortgagee so that it is notified if the policy is canceled or if insurance proceeds are paid after a loss.
Without acceptable insurance coverage in place, the lender will generally refuse to close the loan.
Insurance Costs Are Included in Housing Expenses
When qualifying a borrower, lenders examine the applicant’s ability to repay the loan. One of the primary calculations used during underwriting is the debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, which compares the borrower’s monthly debt obligations to the borrower’s gross monthly income.
The proposed monthly housing payment generally includes:
• Principal
• Interest
• Property taxes
• Homeowners insurance
• Mortgage insurance, if applicable
• Homeowners association dues, if applicable
Because homeowners insurance is included in the monthly housing payment, higher insurance premiums directly increase the borrower’s monthly obligations.
For example, assume a buyer qualifies comfortably with a monthly homeowners insurance premium of $125. If insurance premiums increase to $450 per month because of wildfire risk, the monthly housing payment increases by $325. For some borrowers, this increase may cause the debt-to-income ratio to exceed the lender’s maximum allowable limit, resulting in a loan denial or requiring the borrower to qualify for a smaller loan.
Rising Premiums Reduce Purchasing Power
Many homebuyers focus primarily on the purchase price and interest rate when determining what they can afford. However, increasing insurance premiums reduce purchasing power because lenders qualify borrowers based upon the total monthly payment rather than the loan amount alone.
Consider the following example:
Buyer A qualifies for a monthly housing payment of $3,500.
Property taxes equal $600 per month.
Insurance originally costs $150 per month.
The buyer can therefore devote approximately $2,750 toward principal and interest.
If insurance premiums increase to $500 per month, only $2,400 remains available for principal and interest. As a result, the buyer qualifies for a smaller mortgage loan even though income has not changed.
Higher insurance premiums effectively reduce affordability.
Insurance Availability Has Become a Major Issue
In some parts of California, particularly areas exposed to wildfires, obtaining insurance may be more difficult than simply paying a higher premium. Several insurance companies have limited new policies or withdrawn from certain markets because of increased wildfire exposure and rising claim costs.
As a result, buyers may receive multiple insurance denials before finding a company willing to issue a policy.
This can delay the loan approval process because lenders require proof of insurance before closing.
Real estate agents often encourage buyers to obtain insurance quotes early in the escrow process rather than waiting until the final week before closing.
The California FAIR Plan
When traditional insurance companies decline to insure a property, some homeowners may obtain basic property insurance through the California FAIR Plan.
The California FAIR Plan is an insurance program created to provide basic fire insurance to property owners who cannot obtain coverage in the voluntary insurance market. It serves as an insurer of last resort rather than a replacement for traditional homeowners insurance.
Because FAIR Plan policies generally provide limited coverage, homeowners often purchase a separate Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy to obtain additional protection for perils such as liability, theft, water damage, and other risks not covered by the FAIR Plan.
The combined cost of a FAIR Plan policy and a supplemental DIC policy may be substantially higher than a traditional homeowners insurance policy.
These higher premiums can affect loan qualification in the same manner as any other increase in housing expenses.
Escrow Accounts and Insurance Payments
Most residential mortgage loans require borrowers to establish an escrow (impound) account.
Each month, the borrower pays one-twelfth of the estimated annual property taxes and homeowners insurance premium along with the mortgage payment. The lender deposits these funds into the escrow account and pays the insurance company when the annual premium becomes due.
When insurance premiums increase, the lender performs an annual escrow analysis.
If the escrow account contains insufficient funds to pay the increased premium, the borrower may be required to:
• Pay a lump-sum escrow shortage.
• Increase the monthly escrow payment.
• Or both.
Although this occurs after closing rather than during loan approval, it demonstrates how rising insurance costs continue affecting homeowners throughout the life of the loan.
Lender Insurance Requirements
Lenders establish minimum insurance requirements before approving a mortgage loan.
Typical requirements include:
• Coverage equal to at least the replacement cost of the improvements or the amount required by the lender.
• An insurer that meets the lender’s financial standards.
• The lender listed as mortgagee or loss payee.
• Coverage remaining in force throughout the loan term.
If a borrower cannot obtain insurance meeting these standards, the lender may refuse to fund the loan.
Force-Placed Insurance
If a homeowner allows the required insurance policy to lapse after closing, the lender may purchase insurance on the property to protect its own financial interest. This is commonly known as force-placed insurance or lender-placed insurance.
Force-placed insurance generally protects only the lender’s interest in the property and often provides less coverage than a standard homeowners policy. It typically does not protect the homeowner’s personal belongings or provide liability coverage.
In addition, force-placed insurance is frequently much more expensive than insurance purchased directly by the homeowner. The lender adds the premium to the borrower’s loan obligations, increasing the monthly payment.
Because of its higher cost and limited protection, borrowers should maintain their own homeowners insurance whenever possible.
Special Considerations for Condominiums
Insurance requirements for condominium purchases differ somewhat from those for single-family residences.
The homeowners association generally carries a master insurance policy covering the building and common areas. Individual unit owners usually purchase an HO-6 condominium insurance policy covering personal property, interior improvements, liability, and other items not insured under the association’s master policy.
Lenders review both the association’s master policy and the buyer’s individual policy before approving many condominium loans.
If either policy fails to satisfy lender requirements, loan approval may be delayed.
Shopping for Insurance Early
Because insurance availability varies significantly depending upon location, buyers should obtain insurance quotes before removing contingencies whenever possible.
Obtaining quotes early allows buyers to:
• Estimate the true monthly housing payment.
• Determine whether the property is insurable.
• Compare premiums from multiple companies.
• Avoid unexpected underwriting problems.
• Decide whether the purchase remains affordable.
This has become especially important in wildfire-prone regions where insurance options may be limited.
Impact on Sellers
Rising insurance costs affect sellers as well as buyers.
A property that is difficult or expensive to insure may attract fewer qualified buyers because some purchasers cannot obtain financing or no longer qualify after insurance premiums are calculated.
Sellers located in high-risk areas may therefore experience longer marketing times, increased requests for insurance information, or negotiations concerning insurance availability.
Providing prospective buyers with recent insurance information, when available, may help reduce uncertainty during escrow.
The Future of Insurance and Lending
Insurance costs are likely to remain an important component of mortgage underwriting. As climate risks, construction costs, and catastrophic losses continue influencing the insurance industry, lenders will continue evaluating insurance affordability as part of the borrower’s overall financial profile.
Borrowers who understand how insurance affects loan qualification are better prepared to estimate their purchasing power, avoid surprises during underwriting, and make informed purchasing decisions.
Key Point
Rising homeowners insurance premiums affect much more than the cost of owning a home. Because insurance is included in a borrower’s monthly housing expense, higher premiums can reduce purchasing power, increase debt-to-income ratios, delay loan approval, or even prevent financing altogether. Obtaining insurance quotes early, understanding lender requirements, and budgeting for insurance costs have become essential steps in today’s California real estate market.





